Hicans represent an intriguing option for agroforestry practitioners seeking to expand nut production into regions where traditional pecans struggle. These naturally occurring hybrids between hickories and pecans combine the cold hardiness and adaptability of hickories with the thinner-shelled nuts more typical of pecans. While less well-known than their parent species, hicans offer unique advantages for diversified farming systems across a wide geographic range. So why are hicans still a niche curiosity?
Understanding Hicans
Hicans are hybrids resulting from crosses between pecan trees (Carya illinoinensis) and various hickory species, most commonly shagbark hickory (Carya ovata) or shellbark hickory (Carya laciniosa). These crosses can occur naturally where ranges overlap, though most commercially available hicans come from intentional breeding programs.
The resulting trees display characteristics intermediate between their parents: they’re typically hardier than pecans, more productive than hickories, and produce nuts with shells thinner than hickories but thicker than pecans. The nut kernels often have a flavor profile combining the rich sweetness of pecans with the distinctive, sometimes more pronounced taste of hickories.
Trees are large, often reaching around 70 feet with broad, round crowns and wide spread, so they need generous spacing (on the order of 40–50 feet in orchard settings).
Many named cultivars exist; shellbark × pecan types tend to have larger nuts, while shagbark × pecan types tend to be more productive in nut number.
Some modern cultivars (for example, James Hican) are selected for improved cold hardiness and disease tolerance to issues like pecan scab and certain foliar diseases, which is important in the lower and central Midwest.
Agroforestry Roles for Hicans
Functionally, hicans can occupy the same design niches as pecan in Midwest agroforestry: nut orchards, alley cropping with row crops or forages, and silvopasture with cool-season pasture underneath.
Because they carry some hickory hardiness, appropriate cultivars can push pecan-type nut production slightly farther north or onto more marginal sites compared with standard pecan, especially where winter lows challenge pecan bud hardiness.
Their tall stature and broad crowns make them suitable for widely spaced tree rows in alley-cropping systems, where annuals or perennials (hay, small grains, or even corn/soy) occupy the alleys and benefit from reduced erosion and improved microclimate.
Production and management considerations
Hicans often take several years to bear, with first nut production roughly 4–8 years after establishment for grafted trees, similar to improved pecan timelines under good management.
As with pecan and hickory, you generally design for long rotation: nut yields increasing over decades while also building long-term timber or fuelwood value in the stand.
Cultivar choice is critical; only a subset of hican selections are reliably productive, so using named, tested cultivars (Bixby, Burlington, Burton, Dooley, James Hican, etc.) matters more than seedling stock if your goal is consistent nut income.
Pollination biology is similar to pecan/hickory, with protandrous/protogynous flowering patterns; some cultivars (such as James Hican) are described as self-fertile, but mixed plantings usually improve set and help stabilize yields.
Ecological and system benefits
As large, long-lived nut trees, hicans provide deep root systems that stabilize soil, reduce erosion, and increase infiltration relative to annual-only systems, addressing some of the runoff and water-quality issues common in the Upper Midwest.
Their perennial canopy sequesters carbon and can moderate wind and temperature extremes across adjacent crop alleys or pastures, similar to pecan-based agroforestry plantings.
Nut and foliage production supports wildlife (squirrels, birds, invertebrates), which can be either a benefit (biodiversity, hunting value) or a management issue depending on site goals.
Niche and special uses
In diversified nut enterprises, hicans can occupy a specialty niche—direct-market nuts with a distinct flavor story (“half hickory, half pecan”) for value-added products like baked goods, nut butters, or mixed nut packs etc.
In farm layouts focused on aesthetics and shade (farmsteads, U-pick, agritourism), hicans’ attractive foliage and large crown can double as ornamental shade while also producing a saleable nut crop.
Why aren’t Hicans more popular?
The main reasons hicans have stayed niche are biological inconsistency, lack of standardized cultivars, and weak industry infrastructure compared with pecan and shagbark hickory.
Biological and breeding challenges
Hicans are wide hybrids between pecan and hickory, so seedlings segregate heavily; nut size, shell thickness, and productivity are highly variable and hard to predict from seed.
That variability means you must rely on grafted clones of a few superior trees, but the number of rigorously tested hican cultivars is small compared with pecan or black walnut.
Many hican genotypes are irregular bearers or have poor kernel fill in marginal climates, making them a risky focus for long-term breeding programs relative to straight pecan.
Agronomic and climatic fit
Hicans are often discussed as a way to push pecan-like nuts a bit farther north than standard pecan, but they still share long-season and large-tree constraints; they do not solve the basic issues of tree size, juvenile period, and harvest logistics.
Extension literature tends to present them as a cold-tolerant curiosity or home-orchard option on the northern fringe of pecan country, rather than as a primary commercial crop, which discourages large-scale plantings.
Market and industry factors
Pecan already has a mature, well-funded industry (American Pecan Council, national branding, export markets) and a clear consumer identity; it is far easier for researchers and growers to get funding and marketing traction with pecan than with an obscure hybrid.
There is no comparable commodity board, check‑off program, or processor network for hicans, so there is little coordinated incentive to invest in promotion, product development, or consumer education.
Consumer awareness and product identity
Most consumers have never heard of hicans, and the name does not immediately communicate taste, use, or advantages over pecans; processors would have to educate the market from scratch while competing with an established nut.
Retail and food manufacturers overwhelmingly specify pecans in formulations; a small, inconsistent supply of hicans makes it hard to build SKUs, branding, and recipes around them at scale.
Research priorities and path dependence
Public nut-tree programs (e.g., university and USDA breeding) have finite resources and have historically prioritized major crops: pecan, black walnut, hazelnut, chestnut, etc., where incremental gains translate to large acreage impacts.
Once germplasm collections, trials, and industry partnerships are built around those species, it becomes path‑dependent; shifting significant effort to a hybrid like hican is hard to justify without a strong industry pull or clear, unique advantage.
For a small diversified farm or agroforestry planting, hicans can still be interesting: niche direct‑to‑consumer sales, cold‑tolerant pecan‑type flavor, and differentiation in a local market, but they lack the genetic uniformity, infrastructure, and consumer recognition that drive broad commercialization.
Although we have no hicans planted at this time, this is a tree we are definitely considering. A likely path:
Plant a Trial block: 0.25–0.5 acre
10–20 grafted hicans of 3–4 cultivars (whatever we can source: Burton, Wright, James, Marquardt, Vernon, NT-92, Pleas, McAllister, Henke, Burlington)
Spacing around 35–40 ft
Use hicans to study hybrid vigor and adaptation
Use scionwood from good producers on our specific site that have good nut charactecteristics, and graft these – scale of planting could grow in future, to be determined.
Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I use or would use on my own farm. Read my full disclosure policy.